The South Needs the Clean Water Rule

For drinking water, flood control, climate defense, habitat protection, fishing, swimming, and, of course, craft beer.
Congaree National Park, in South Carolina

Congaree National Park

South Carolina’s Congaree National Park is a small swamp off the beaten track, but like so many wetlands, it’s well connected—like a capillary within the country’s freshwater ecosystem. The swamp feeds the veins of the Congaree and Santee Rivers before its waters eventually join the pulsing Atlantic. According to a 1990 report by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, the Congaree Swamp removes as much pollution annually as a $5 million wastewater treatment facility.

Nevertheless, President Trump’s recent executive order to roll back the Clean Water Rule (also called the Waters of the United States Rule) threatens the Congaree, along with the rest of the nation’s wetlands and rivers and as much as 59 percent of all stream miles. The consequences for drinking water, flooding, and coastal protection are huge.

“Laws are in place to prevent oil companies, fly-by-night dumpers of hazardous waste, and coal companies from just dumping crap in rivers and little streams,” says Jan Goldman-Carter, the director of wetlands and water resources for the National Wildlife Federation (NWF). (On top of contaminating drinking water and destroying favorite fishing spots, Goldman-Carter notes, this type of the pollution threatens the production of craft beer.)

But since the Clean Water Act was passed in 1972, polluting industries have fought to limit which waterways are worthy of protection. They’ve particularly challenged the inclusion of source waters—the waterways that flow into rivers, lakes, and oceans. Supreme Court decisions during the George W. Bush presidency created uncertainty about which waters qualify; then the Obama administration restored protections for many vulnerable waters with the Clean Water Rule.

When the EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers finalized the rule in 2015, they did so recognizing that stopping polluters on, say, the banks of the Mississippi River is not enough. You also have to stop them from contaminating the small tributaries and streams that feed into the Mississippi.

That all waterways are connected, however, isn’t a concept President Trump seems to grasp. His executive order, issued earlier this year, asks Scott Pruitt, the new EPA chief, to exclude isolated wetlands and many rivers and streams from protection, falsely claiming the Clean Water Rule will hurt the agriculture industry and regulate “every puddle.” (The EPA has repeatedly assured farmers that the rule does not create new requirements for the agriculture industry.)

“People like to pit the health of the environment and the economy against each other,” says Megan Desrosiers, executive director of One Hundred Miles, a coastal advocacy group based in Brunswick, Georgia. “But that’s not how it works.”

The concern is that carrying out the executive order will kill the existing rule and replace it with one that not only reverses protections for streams and wetlands, but also interprets the Clean Water Act in ways it wasn’t intended, says Jon Devine, senior attorney in NRDC’s Water program.

Here’s what all that would mean for the South.

Not only is natural filtration at risk. So too is natural flood control. Sometimes, wetlands have two safety nets—federal laws and state laws. But not all states, Georgia for one, have wetlands protections. So, if the EPA nixes the Clean Water Rule, it would be open season on many wetlands that developers could buy, fill, and pave over at will. Of course, more concrete would create more runoff, which leads to more flooding. The region’s intensified rains associated with climate change would then only further exacerbate the problem.

While wetlands right on the coast are not in jeopardy, those farther from the shore but still in the coastal plain are. Disrupting those wetlands would weaken the land’s defenses against sea-level rise. The sediments the wetlands receive from upstream help build resilience. As seas rise, that sediment gets pushed back, allowing the marsh to slowly creep inland. Should parts of South Carolina and Georgia’s coastal plain become hardened or drained by development, they will lose the ability to move with the rising tide and instead will slowly disappear into the sea—along with all their buffering benefits.

Great Blue Heron looking over the murky waters of Okefenokee Swamp

Warren Price/Shutterstock

Last but not least, the drinking water of 20 million southerners (including five million Georgians and two million South Carolinians) is in jeopardy. “In these streams and creeks you have water intakes for drinking water, and if the feeder streams get piped or destroyed in some way, then essentially you are jeopardizing the drinking water for a lot of people,” says Bill Sapp, an attorney at the Southern Environmental Law Center (SELC) who focuses on wetlands and coastal issues and says his group is going to fight like crazy to combat the executive order.

That battle has already begun. NRDC, NWF, and SELC, on behalf of One Hundred Miles and the Coastal Conservation League, have asked the Supreme Court to prevent the Trump administration from indefinitely obstructing the implementation of the Clean Water Rule. The Supreme Court agreed, but the legal war is not nearly over, and Pruitt is inviting state leaders to Washington this week to discuss his plans for the Clean Water Rule’s undoing.

“It’s a mess,” says Sapp. “And as long as Trump’s in the White House, it’s going to be a mess.” But a mess he and his partners are dedicated to cleaning up.

Southeast Dispatch

The rollback jeopardizes the streams that flow into the state’s rivers, lakes, and bays, millions of acres of wetlands across the country, and the drinking water supply.


More than 100 craft breweries from across the country, including Brooklyn Brewery and New Belgium Brewing Company, are joining NRDC to explain why clean water is essential for great-tasting beer.

Southeast Dispatch

As the sea rises, low-income neighborhoods on high land are starting to feel squeezed out.

Southeast Dispatch

The National Climate Assessment’s outlook for the two coastal states is daunting, but local leaders are starting to dig in for a fight.

onEarth Story

As the Trump administration ratchets up its rhetoric demanding billions for a wall, American communities along the Mexico border are in need of basic services, like reliable sewage treatment.

Midwest Dispatch

As the state’s dairy farms get bigger, cow poop is polluting Lake Michigan and people’s drinking water.

onEarth Story

Plus, hawking coal at a climate summit and selling out polar bears to Big Oil.

NRDC in Action

These four NRDC lawyers would finish each other’s thoughts—at any odd hour of the day or night—in their quest to help victims of the city’s lead crisis.

Personal Action

Quick and easy things you can do to reduce water pollution and runoff.

Policy Primer

Climate change is causing more floods and more damage along our coasts and our inland waterways. It’s not only sinking people’s homes, but sinking our country’s disaster response budget.


Everything you need to know in order to fill a glass from your faucet with confidence.

Ginger Unzueta/Offset
Policy Primer

The Trump administration wants to open our waterways back up to pollution.

Kathryn Smith/USGS
onEarth Story

The oil and gas industry says, “not it.”

What's At Stake

The regulations that protect Americans’ health, economy, and environment now need our protection.

Southeast Dispatch

As the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers considers including “living shorelines” among its preferred erosion controls, Alabama is already leading the way to healthier coasts.

Southeast Dispatch

Southern communities prefer their coastlines sandy, beautiful, and bountiful—not filled with rigs and air guns blasting ships or covered in oil.

Ria Tan/Flickr
onEarth Story

Ocean acidification takes the "snap" out of snapping shrimp.

Western Dispatch

Local groups and government agencies are working together to remediate this Superfund site in the city’s midst, despite diminishing support from the EPA.

Southeast Dispatch

A city must decide whether to retreat or stand and fight when rising seas come crashing in.

Northeast Dispatch

The Big Apple’s combined sewer system is 150 years old—and in desperate need of improvement.

NRDC in Action

For years, states could ignore global warming when creating their disaster-preparedness plans. Not anymore.


Our rivers, reservoirs, lakes, and seas are drowning in chemicals, waste, plastic, and other pollutants. Here’s why―and what you can do to help.

Southeast Dispatch

The Southeast has the hospitable weather and the shallow waters—but does it have the will?

Latest News

Here’s why this environmental and public health win is so important.


U.S. veteran Paul A. Schwarz, Jr. died from eating a piece of cantaloupe in a fruit cup—all because of a lack of food-safety protections.

Southeast Dispatch

And the Trump administration’s gutting of the Endangered Species Act will only make things worse.


Two brothers tell the story of how their mother died from eating peanut butter, all from a lack of food-safety inspections.

Latest News

The Trump administration’s slapdash approval process for fossil fuel projects just isn’t standing up to legal review.

Join Us

When you sign up you'll become a member of NRDC's Activist Network. We will keep you informed with the latest alerts and progress reports.