When a Study Singled Out Memphis’s Unfairly High Power Bills, Grassroots Groups Took Action
The electric bill that arrives in homes around Memphis, Tennessee, every month is unlike any other in the nation. Residents here bear the country’s highest energy burden―the percentage of income spent on electricity. In fact, Memphis families spend twice as much as the average American household just to keep the lights, air-conditioning, and refrigerator running.
“In Memphis, we’ve seen as much as 26 percent of people’s income going to energy bills, which is outrageous,” says Sandra Upchurch, energy organizer for the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy (SACE). The national average is closer to 3.5 percent, and 7 percent is the norm for low-income households. “When your income is low, even an average electricity bill can be a big burden.”
The high cost of utilities didn’t happen overnight in this city known as the center of blues music. A tangled web of poverty, poor investment in energy efficiency, and a history of disenfranchisement of the city’s communities of color has produced a wide range of negative economic, health, and environmental impacts. That’s why a number of nonprofit groups—including the Memphis branch of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), Sierra Club, SACE, and Friends of the Earth—are working to improve life in Memphis, starting where it’s needed most: at home.
In 2016, the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy and Energy Efficiency for All (of which NRDC is a core partner) published a report that brought the concept of energy burden into the public eye. It ranked cities by energy costs relative to income and revealed that low-income residents of color spent a monthly average of $1.23 per square foot of home size, while those in higher income brackets paid $0.98 per square foot. Despite having low electricity prices in general, Memphis topped the list in the study, with several other cities in the Southeast close behind.
Here’s why: Without the resources to maintain or improve their homes, low-income residents often can’t afford cost-saving upgrades like closing drafty cracks, adding insulation, and installing newer, more energy-efficient appliances. As a result, their inefficient, leaky homes become even more expensive to power. It’s part of the cycle of poverty that relegates low-income people of color to areas of their city where energy costs, ironically, are sometimes higher than in newer, better-maintained neighborhoods.
One way to close the divide, says Amelia Shenstone, SACE’s regional advocacy director, is for utilities to improve existing programs that help with weatherization and other efficiency measures and to increase access to renewable energy options for low-income clients. In addition to improving the energy performance of individual homes, these programs contribute to better air quality for the entire community.
But here’s the rub: Memphis is supposed to have these programs already. A few years back, the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA), the federally owned utility that supplies Memphis’s municipal power company, offered a one-time funding opportunity called the Extreme Energy Makeover Program. The program provided funds for home weatherization and energy efficiency improvements.
But out of more than $40 million allotted to cities, Memphis, TVA’s largest customer, received zero dollars. “We see the lack of investment in energy efficiency as targeted against our people,” says SACE’s Upchurch. “We are their largest customer, bringing in $1.5 billion a year, yet it’s as if they take us for granted because we are a minority-majority city. They want to keep the cycle of poverty going.”
Eventually, under pressure from SACE and NAACP, TVA did give Memphis Light, Gas and Water (MLGW) $1 million in low-income home weatherization grants through another program. “TVA has a long history of working closely with MLGW and the city of Memphis to address the needs of residential customers and, in particular, fixed- and lower-income residents,” says TVA spokesperson Jim Hopson. “This collaboration has been quite active in recent years with nearly $8 million in direct support from 2008 to the present, touching over 14,000 Memphis families.”
MLGW’s own Share the Pennies program rounds up residential customers’ utility bills to the next dollar and uses the extra funds collected to support low-income families. But at the current funding levels, it would reportedly take a century for the program to help all residents in need, according to SACE.
Other examples of energy advocacy in the city include SACE’s Memphis Has the Power campaign, a petition drive that urges TVA to focus on energy efficiency and renewable energy, and the Strong, Prosperous, and Resilient Communities Challenge, led by NRDC and three national partners investing $20 million in grants in six localities over three years to fund equitable community development.
Despite its history of inequality, Memphis is actually well positioned to be a leader in the Southeast when it comes to lowering the energy burden of its citizens. The power company is municipally owned rather than privately held, which means taxpayers can demand a say in how the company is managed. Ultimately, that’s good for the utility itself, its customers, and the community as a whole, says Katie Southworth, a consultant for NRDC’s Southeast Energy team, who calls it “the democratization of public power.”
The goal, she says, is for utilities to realize that weatherization and energy efficiency programs for those with low incomes are a win-win. Such programs strengthen the utility, put more money in the pockets of its customers, and benefit the environment. And they level the playing field for all. “Tackling energy burden is a step in the right direction toward a more just energy economy in the Southeast,” says Southworth.
Dawone Robinson, regional director of NRDC’s Energy Efficiency for All Project, works to create opportunities for low-income communities of color to save energy and money.
Dawone Robinson is righting the inequities that low-income communities of color face in accessing the benefits of energy efficiency—like more comfortable homes and lower energy bills, for starters.
Fun fact: In most of the country, there’s a daily auction to sell energy into our power grids—with the least expensive sources winning. Also noteworthy: Coal’s not cheap.
Khalil Shahyd had a hand in helping his hometown recover from Katrina, and now he advocates for climate resiliency on behalf of vulnerable communities nationwide.
A new documentary shows how trust and respect can be seeds for thriving communities.
The country’s prison industry has little regard for where its facilities are located—even if that means building on noxiously polluted ground.
No demolition required. A few small tweaks to each room could dramatically shrink your carbon footprint.
Environmental awareness and social justice mix provocatively at the Whitney Museum’s new show, “Between the Waters”
Small steps can add up to big reductions in your electricity use—and your utility bill.
The largely African-American community of Dobbins Heights hopes to protect its health—and its trees—from the biomass industry.
Thanks to advances in turbine tech, the first commercial-scale wind farm in the Southeast is about to get whirring.
NRDC senior scientist Lara Ettenson is determined to bridge social, economic, and cultural divides by advancing clean energy in California.
Environmental pioneer James Gustave Speth says the fights for democracy and nature should join forces.
Here’s what you need to know about energy efficiency and how you can help save the environment—and money—at the same time.
For activist Bryan Parras, a native of Houston’s refinery-filled east side, the personal is very much the political.
Here’s how they’re getting started.
Let’s take a deeper look into last week’s energy efficiency bombshell.
Trump likens our “inner cities” to war zones . . . then guts the programs geared to safeguard clean air and water for low-income communities of color.
Injustice comes in many forms.